Game of Thrones Embraces Shock Value Rape

Posted: May 18, 2015 in Uncategorized

By Muttonface

CFQmuJPUEAAmFN0

Rape is rarely done well when it pertains to fiction. It is a byproduct of the rape culture in which we live, spun off into a yarn for one reason or another that inevitably leads to the only conclusion: the objectification and victim blaming of women. I guess she shouldn’t have been wearing that wedding gown.

If rape can be said to handled “well” in the media, it is done with regards to the plot. Its done correct when that act becomes a large part of the character’s plot, and the character can be shown to realistically deal with the years of pain and emotional trauma caused by the act. In Sansa’s case, then, her violation in last night’s episode does not make sense in regards to her overall arc as a character. Her being raped does not further her character or her story whatsoever. After last night’s feelings of disgust and anger faded, it was replaced with confusion. Why exactly was that raped depicted, and so resoundingly in the final scene of the episode?

Game of Thrones writer Bryan Cogman went so far as to explain that Littlefinger didn’t know the Boltons were like that, and that Sansa made a “choice.” They do not even view the scene as rape. Smacks of Jaime/Cersei last season when they defended the scene as consensual and never mentioned it again on screen.

Then they cut to Theon to show his pain as if that’s what we all cared about. They made the scene of a female’s rape and humiliation about a male character in order for a male character to find redemption.

It should be noted that rapes do occur in A Song of Ice and Fire. But for the most part, they take place off-screen (or off-page, as it were) and mostly occur during war. In fact, GRRM makes sure to note in many incidents that the rapist’s “blood” was up, making a special dispensation for something that has occurred in armed conflict in medieval times and our own. In this, ASoIaF is unique.

unnamed7

The series, however, is a different story. Rapes that occur in HBO’s Game of Thrones usually happen to unfortunate female characters who are not raped in the books. Meera Reed. Cersei. And Sansa, a scene so polarizing and graphic that emotions are rightly running high with both book lovers and show-watching “book burners.” They have changed so much from the books this season that the defense “its in the books” is completely inane. Its clear: From the start of the season, HBO decided Sansa was sent to Winterfell for this scene, and this scene only. To be raped.

Two grown men waited until their child actor was of age and then had the most sadistic character in the series rape her. Let that sink in. I’ll wait.

When rape is depicted in media it is usually a plot device to strengthen a woman’s character. This is a vile notion that is at the heart of patriarchal thought.

I can just imagine the gaggle of fedora-wearing neckbeards that HBO employs going through writing this scene:

“Hey, what if Sansa gets raped? It doesn’t happen in the books, so it’s shocking, and she’ll have to deal with it and become a deeper character and stuff! Everyone will be talking about it! We will win Twitter!!!”

It should be noted that in the books at this point Sansa is trying her best to be a surrogate mother for Robin at the Vale or dancing with Ser Harry Hardyng, coming into her own as a strong woman and as Alayne Stone, herself rather than the name she was born to as a Stark. She is maturing and gaining agency, and preparing to take her rightful place on the world stage as the daughter of Eddard Stark and Catelyn Tully. I suppose that that doesn’t make for good television, however. Guess that wasn’t “rapey” enough for HBO.

unnamed3

With Sansa having been raped (even though HBO and, absurdly, many fans denying or defending this) Game of Thrones has finally cast off any doubt in many minds on whether or not it is palatable any longer. The ending of Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken parallels many of the moments in the series about which we still talk. Ned losing his head, Barristan dying, Viserys being crowned, dragons being born. Unlike those episode ending scenes, however, last night’s leaves a foul taste in the mouth, plenty of questions, distaste, and a sad resignation that senseless rape on television is here to stay.

sansa_stark_1_0_by_daenerys_mod-d4hwysi

If you or someone you know is a victim of sexual or domestic abuse, here are two links that can help you on the journey to healing:

https://www.rainn.org/

https://www.stoprapenow.org/

Advertisements
Comments
  1. downszdiva says:

    I’m so glad to read your tweets last night because I had a panic attack during that scene. Scandal last season had a scene like this, to show what made one female character “stronger” (and perhaps to explain away her bitchiness) was when she was raped by her Father in law. What irritates (and continues to do so) is that on GoT, they changed the narrative from the very beginning. Dany was forced the night of her wedding (departure from the books), Ros got a better life and then bam! used as a torture device by Joffrey.
    It took me a year to watch season 1 because of that first violent scene with Drogo’s indifference to Dany’s suffering. I wondered if this was a show I should watch. I’m having the same thoughts now, after seeing what Sansa lived through last night. It’s clear that D&D doesn’t care. And even GRRM went on (see entertainment weekly) to grouse about all the angry emails he received last night. He had a poor excuse, that events are being set in place for the future. But if so, why must it be done on the backs of beaten, murdered, (dog attacked like Tansy) scenes at the expense of women? It really scares me that many fans are defending and insisting that it wasn’t rape, that Sansa submitted. Yes!!! Can you believe that?

  2. Eric says:

    Firstly, Id like to believe you wrote that. There were some great insights here and there. Secondly, I agree it was confusing and left a bad taste in my mouth as well. I also applaud you for raising the issue of “victim blaming”. However I don’t agree that it was without meaning. And I don’t agree that it was for “shock value”. We all know Ramsey at this point, we know what kind of sick fuck he is. Sansa had a mere inkling of his nature. It wasn’t shocking for us as viewers or for her as a character as she had to expect that her wedding night would be unpleasant, rape or not. She’s playing the game and biding her time. The real emotional depth to the scene was Theon’s/Reek’s. And downplaying that aspect with some veiled disgust doesn’t do any favors to that article. Pointing a righteous finger at that scene seems more like using (or misusing) pro-feminist issues in your continuing crusade to slander a show that has departed from its source material. What you book worshipers consider to be a mortal sin.

    • ApeLieUproar says:

      Of course it was for shock value. What other purpose does it serve? It sure doesn’t advance Sansa Stark at all.

  3. dennis says:

    Sorry dude but i gotta disagree. You made the point that mirrored acts of sexual violence have taken place in our world with an equatibal social system. I have to ask do you think these acts immediatley became the defining factor for the victims? If not then you have to accept that a world rife with violence will have little sympathy for someone who has endured violence (in or out of war).
    As to blaming the victim?? How you came to the assertion that because she was wearing a wedding dress she was to blame is a a complete mystery to me, the show did not make this an iron clad dialouge point and to jump on the idea and run worries me. You can only blame the victim if thats how you think otherwise regardless of what is said or done the blame will always lie with the person who commits the act.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s